Should I accept a higher sale price if the buyer wants me to finance part of the purchase?
Compare the offers by expected after-tax cash you can actually collect, not headline price. A larger purchase price with a seller note is economically different from cash at closing. The additional price may compensate you for financing risk, or it may simply disguise that risk.
Separate each offer into cash at closing, fixed deferred payments and contingent consideration. A holdback subject to indemnification claims is not equivalent to an unconditional payment obligation. An earnout dependent on future performance adds another layer of uncertainty.
For the seller-financed portion, evaluate:
- The buyer's financial strength and cash invested in the acquisition.
- The interest rate, repayment schedule and final balloon payment.
- Collateral value, lien priority and any payment restrictions imposed by senior lenders.
- Your ability to meet personal spending needs if payments stop.
Have your advisors compare the present value of the payment streams and stress-test delayed or incomplete collection. Use a discount rate that reflects the actual credit risk rather than treating the note like cash in a savings account.
Section 453 may spread recognition of eligible gain as payments arrive, but tax deferral does not insure repayment. Cash received at closing can accelerate gain recognition, while interest is generally taxed separately as ordinary income.
The recommendation: negotiate the cash-at-closing amount first. Accept deferred consideration only when the financing terms and realistic collection prospects justify the risk, not merely because the advertised price or projected tax deferral looks larger.
Category: Seller Financing Risk